Are you remodeling your home and want to upgrade your windows? Are you also considering vinyl and aluminum, and came here to learn about their differences? In either case, you are in the right place.
In this article, we will discuss everything you need to know about vinyl vs aluminum windows. We’ll share their differences in terms of design, cost, durability, and energy efficiency.
By the end, you’ll know which window type is the better choice for your home. Let’s begin with a brief introduction to both of these materials.
What are Aluminium Windows?
Aluminum windows are the ones with frames made of aluminum. It is a light and robust type of metal that can create light and slender body frames. Due to this fact, such windows can make homes look contemporary and with large chunks of glass.
They last a long time and can take up to 20–25 years to complete. They also handle extremely adverse weather without any issues. In terms of aluminum vs vinyl window frames, aluminum is generally preferred due to its modern design and strength.
If you prefer aluminum, consider these beautiful and durable aluminum doors and windows as well. These are made of high-quality Aluminum and have affordable pricing.
What Are Vinyl Windows?
Vinyl windows are composed of hardened plastic known as PVC. The frames are thicker than aluminium, but quite insulating to the home. They keep your home warm in winter and even help you save some money on heating costs.
Unlike aluminum, they don’t need to rust and corrode. That’s why they are an excellent option for coastal homes. Moreover, they can serve for many years without losing their quality. The only problem is that after that, you cannot paint them, so you should choose a color that you like initially.
Alongside the windows, if you are also looking for doors, you should consult George Construction's door and window catalog.
Vinyl vs Aluminum Windows: Detailed Comparison
Vinyl and aluminum are the two most popular non-wood alternatives to window frames that homeowners use. These are more readily available, less prone to weathering compared to wood, and are less costly compared to fiberglass or composite materials.
But beyond these similarities, their differences become clear. Let’s understand these by comparing them in terms of key features below.
Appearance
You can customize both aluminum and vinyl windows, but they still have distinct appearances. Here are some appearance differences between vinyl windows vs aluminum windows.
| Feature | Aluminum Windows | Vinyl Windows |
| Frame Thickness | Thinner frame for more glass area | Slightly thicker, traditional frame |
| Style | Sleek, modern, contemporary | Mimics wood for traditional or classic looks |
| Finishes | Smooth, textured, or enamel-coated | Smooth, textured, or faux-wood grain |
| Repainting | Can be repainted with enamel paint | Cannot be repainted (painting voids warranty) |
Aluminum Windows: Aluminum window frames are narrow. They provide you with more glass rooms. It allows much sunshine in. They also make a good living in contemporary houses.
They also fit with industrial-style designs. The frames are typically enamel, with a very fine finish. The advantage of aluminum is that it can be painted when the colour wears off or is scratched. It restores them to their natural appearance.
Vinyl Windows: Their frames are heavier than those of aluminum. They are available in numerous tints and designs, and even resemble real wood.
These are a good choice if you love the appearance of traditional windows but desire the energy efficiency of modern windows. However, there is one drawback: vinyl frames cannot be repainted in the future. So you need to select their color carefully.
Verdict: Aluminum would be a good choice because they have a very thin frame with a sleek appearance. Vinyl is the better option in case you want a wood-like look or multiple design options.
Durability
Now let’s compare these two materials in terms of durability. Before we compare them with each other, let me tell you that both are more durable than wood. However, vinyl and aluminum react differently with environmental conditions. Let's check out their primary differences in terms of durability.
| Feature | Aluminum Windows | Vinyl Windows |
| Lifespan | 20–25 years | 10–40 years (depending on quality) |
| Weather Resistance | Strong in extreme heat & cold | Performs well in most climates, but extreme heat may cause warping |
| Coastal Suitability | Not recommended (salt corrosion) | Better than aluminum in coastal areas |
| Damage Visibility | Chips and dents are noticeable | Minor damage is less visible |
Aluminum Windows: Aluminum is a strong material that can support the big, thick windows. It is efficient in both cold and warm weather. Nevertheless, in coastal regions, saltwater tends to loosen it up and make it crumble. Its enamel may also fade over a more extended period of exposure to the sun.
Vinyl Windows: When you buy premium vinyl windows, they can last for 40 years. They are not corrosive like aluminum, hence they will perform well in moist or seashore areas. However, poor-quality vinyl can be damaged in hot climates.
Verdict: When it comes to vinyl vs. aluminum windows, aluminum is generally more durable. However, for warm or coastal areas, vinyl is a better option.
Cost
It is a very important factor whether you are buying aluminum or vinyl windows. Here is a comparison table of vinyl vs aluminum window costs.
| Material | Average Cost per Window | Installation |
| Aluminum Window Cost | $75 – $400 | + $100–$300 per window |
| Vinyl Windows Cost | $100 – $900 | + $100–$300 per window |
Replacing eight vinyl window frames would cost you about $7,200 in materials. However, if you use aluminum, you may save up to $4,000 for comparable work..
Verdict: When comparing vinyl vs aluminum windows in terms of cost, aluminum is generally more expensive. However, if you are also considering the cost of energy savings, vinyl may be a better choice.
One thing you need to keep in mind, despite the material you choose, is that the window sizes matter in terms of cost. If you choose standard window sizes, they will cost much less than custom ones.
Energy Efficiency
Now, let’s compare these two in terms of energy efficiency. It is one of the most important factors, as electricity bills are very expensive almost everywhere in the world.
Aluminum Windows: Aluminum transfers heat and cold. It means your house will be warmer in the summer and cooler in the winter. Thermally improved windows made of aluminum can be purchased, but at a higher price. Even at that, they can never rival vinyl in terms of efficiency.
Vinyl Windows: Vinyl has excellent insulating properties. It reduces heat conduction and helps lower utility costs for cooling and heating. Vinyl windows manufactured under the ENERGY STAR trademark can save you even more on your bills in the long run.
Verdict: Vinyl is the better choice when considering energy efficiency in vinyl vs aluminum windows.
Maintenance
Lastly, let’s compare these material options in terms of maintenance. It is essential, especially if you clean the windows yourself.
| Maintenance Task | Aluminum Windows | Vinyl Windows |
| Cleaning | Regular wipe-downs with aluminum cleaner | Soap and water |
| Corrosion | Must prevent rust and mold | Not an issue |
| Finish | May peel or fade, repainting required | Finish lasts, repainting not possible |
| Caulking | Needs checking to avoid leaks | Needs occasional caulking in extreme climates |
Aluminum Windows: You need to wash these windows regularly to prevent condensation and corrosion. You must also lubricate the operating surfaces so they are smooth. You may need to repaint it as well if the finish cracks or peels.
Vinyl Windows: Vinyl windows are much easier to clean. You can simply wash them with soap or any mild detergent. Remember to check them during extreme temperatures for small cracks or holes. Then, fill them using caulk.
Verdict: Vinyl is a better choice. It is easier to clean and requires very little maintenance compared to Aluminum.
These were all the differences between Vinyl and Aluminum windows. If you have made your decision and are ready to purchase, here are the 10 best door and window manufacturers.
Vinyl Vs. Aluminum Windows: Installation Options
Installing a window is a complex process that can lead to air leakage, water damage, and mold growth. For both materials, there are two options for installation.
Instead, these are the options for every window, even other than these two as well. Each one has its own advantages and disadvantages. Choose the one that matches your needs.
DIY Installation
You will need saws, drills, measuring tools, and sealing materials for this first whether it’s an Aluminum or Vinyl window installation. Secondly, you also need to have the basic skills to use these tools as well. If you have never used any such tools, it’s better to avoid this option.
It is very cheap, but you risk having serious issues if something goes wrong. It breaks easily, shatters windows, and does not fit right are some of the problems that inexperienced people have when they do it. It will also require a significant amount of effort and time.
If you install the windows yourself, pay attention to the rough opening to fit them properly. Read this guide on rough opening for windows to ensure you get everything right.
Professional Installation
It is expensive, but it offers numerous benefits. It saves your time, effort, and ensures windows are level, sealed, and waterproof. Many manufacturers also offer warranties and discounts on their products.
What Should You Choose?
In the case of vinyl vs aluminum windows, Vinyl is flexible and readily installed. In contrast, installing aluminum windows is complex and requires highly accurate measurements.
No matter how minor, a mistake can mar the installation altogether. That’s why we recommend professional services for these windows.
How to Find a Professional for Vinyl and Aluminum Windows Installation?
First, ask your manufacturer for installation services. They will either provide you with these services themselves or connect you with someone who can offer them.
In case there is no other option, carefully research yourself and then choose a professional. Here are a few things to look for while searching for professional installation services.
- Check online reviews and ask people you trust: Read reviews about local installers and ask trusted people you know. Check with friends or relatives to see if anybody knows of a good one.
Investigate the reputation of the company. If you contact online, look for reviews at trusted websites like Trustpilot, etc.
- Compare quotes: Contact at least three good companies. Ask them about their prices, experience, and availability.
- Check licenses and insurance: Find out that the company has the right to operate in your state and has the necessary insurance in case of an accident.
- Ask about the project deadline: Inquire about the estimated completion time for the project.
- Get it all in writing: Ask written estimates, guarantees, or warranties to be given to you so that, in case something happens, you are not screwed.
Conclusion
The answer to vinyl vs aluminum windows is not that simple. It does not depend on the type of window; it depends on your needs, personal choices, and the amount you want to spend.
Vinyl windows are an appropriate choice where low maintenance is a requirement, energy is an issue, and design options are a consideration. However, if you would like a newer look with narrow frames and an emphasis on glass, consider aluminum windows.
Just think about what is most essential for you first, and then you can choose what is best for you. Finally, if you have made up your mind and are prepared to buy, then it is one of the best destinations to make such a purchase. Here’s how to import doors and windows from China. You can save a lot of money by learning it.
